15 Worst Performances in Great Movies, Ranked Find help us

Many factors go into creating a great film, and casting is one of the most crucial and challenging aspects of the process. A perfectly cast role can elevate a movie, making it hard to imagine any other actor in that part. However, a single miscast performer can derail an entire film, no matter how stellar everything else might be. When a movie excels in every aspect, a poorly cast role becomes even more obvious, drawing criticism and overshadowing the film’s success.

Whether it’s due to a lack of chemistry, an unconvincing accent, or simply not meshing with the character’s essence, these missteps stand out. From Cameron Diaz to Quentin Tarantino, these are examples where a single performance missed the mark in an otherwise great movie. These are all great performers, but their work in these movies made it absurdly clear how out of place they were. The ranking will be based on the performance itself, how much it stands out, and whether the film itself is worsened by its presence.

15

Kevin Costner as Robin Hood

‘Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves’ (1991)

The iconic Robin Hood is perhaps one of the fictional characters that have most often been transported to the big screen, and one of the last truly great Robin Hood adaptations was Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves, a traditional yet refreshingly big-budgeted swashbuckler about this legendary hero who steals from the rich to give to the poor.

Prince of Thieves is one of the most entertaining movies based on a public domain character, with a phenomenal Alan Rickman as the Sheriff of Nottingham. There’s just one issue: The guy playing Robin Hood. The role didn’t quite suit Kevin Costner, whose clunky British accent and lack of chemistry with Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio‘s Marian are embarrassing. He can’t quite embody the dashing sincerity and charm of this beloved hero, making him an ill-suited choice for the lead role of such a big movie. —Diego Pineda Pacheco

14

Daryl Hannah as Darien Taylor

‘Wall Street’ (1987)

Wall Street is one of the best dramas of the ’80s, a hard-hitting tale of greed and ambition about an impatient young stockbroker willing to do anything to get to the top, including trading on illegal inside information taken through a ruthless corporate raider who takes the man under his wing. Charlie Sheen and Michael Douglas are phenomenal in the two lead roles. The trifecta is completed by Daryl Hannah, who’s not nearly as good.

Hannah reportedly had an unpleasant experience with director Oliver Stone, so it’s hard to blame her for how little effort she put into this performance, but the fact remains that it’s far from her best. Her character is underwritten enough as it is, serving solely as the lead’s love interest, but Hannah—terribly miscast in the role—doesn’t help make things any better. It’s like she’s sleepwalking through the performance, which doesn’t help the film in the slightest. —Diego Pineda Pacheco

13

Andie MacDowell as Carrie

‘Four Weddings and a Funeral’ (1994)

Andie MacDowell has been in some pretty solid classics, from Groundhog Day to Sex, Lies, and Videotape, but it’s not like she can do no wrong. Case in point: Her performance in Four Weddings and a Funeral, one of the highest-grossing British movies ever made. It’s a satire where, over the course of five social occasions, a committed bachelor has to confront the idea that he may just have found love.

The movie overall is one of the best rom-coms of all time, a delightful little gem with an incredible Hugh Grant in the lead. MacDowell, on the other hand, doesn’t do quite as good a job. To be fair, the character of Carrie is pretty paper-thin, but the utterly wooden work that the actress does to materialize the character makes her even more boring. It’s borderline incomprehensible why or how the main character would ever fall in love with her, and that’s largely MacDowell’s fault. —Diego Pineda Pacheco

12

Cameron Diaz as Jenny Everdeane

‘Gangs of New York’ (2002)

Cameron Diaz in Martin Scorsese‘s Gangs of New York is one of the most infamous cases of star-casting in movie history. Despite her star power, Diaz’s performance didn’t quite hit the mark. Her portrayal of the Irish pickpocket is rather superficial, and her accent drew widespread criticism for being unconvincing, especially against the film’s more grounded performances.

One of the best gangster movies of all time, Gangs of New York delivers powerful performances by Daniel Day-Lewis and Leonardo DiCaprio. The film follows Amsterdam Vallon (DiCaprio), who returns to a gang-ravaged New York to avenge his father’s murder by infiltrating the gang of Bill “The Butcher” Cutting (Day-Lewis). Both actors bring an intensity that elevates the film, making Diaz’s portrayal of Jenny feel even more out of place.

11

Katie Holmes as Rachel Dawes

‘Batman Begins’ (2005)

In an all-star cast, including Christian Bale, Gary Oldman, Cillian Murphy, and Michael Cane, Katie Holmes’ performance as Rachel is the weaker element in Batman Begins. Unlike most characters in the movie, Rachel wasn’t drawn from the DC Comics universe but was created specifically for the film. Holmes was the first choice for the role, but unfortunately, she lacked the intensity the character demanded, and her on-screen chemistry with Bale was non-existent. In a movie brimming with powerhouse performances, Holmes’s take on Rachel fell flat.

In The Dark Knight, Maggie Gyllenhaal replaced Holmes as Rachel, with Holmes’s departure reportedly due to personal choices and scheduling conflicts. Batman Begins still became one of the most influential films of the 2000s, revolutionizing the superhero genre with its darker, grittier tone. It also set the stage for Hollywood’s “reboot” craze, proving that fresh takes on beloved characters could still resonate with audiences in new and exciting ways.

10

Orlando Bloom as Balian of Ibelin

‘Kingdom of Heaven’ (2005)

After wrapping up Troy, Orlando Bloom took on another historical epic movie, Ridley Scott‘s Kingdom of Heaven. Despite his growing fame from the blockbuster The Lord of the Rings and Pirates of the Caribbean, Bloom’s performance as Balian of Ibelin didn’t quite land. Unfortunately, he wasn’t convincing as a hardened warrior dealing with personal tragedy and seeking redemption. Bloom lacked the emotional weight needed for the role, which was essential for the character’s arc.

While the theatrical release of Kingdom of Heaven didn’t make a huge splash, Scott’s director’s cut brought new life into the film. The extended version was praised as one of Scott’s most impressive historical epics, showcasing the movie in its full glory. Known for his hits and misses throughout his career, Scott’s Kingdom of Heaven remains an underrated effort, although Bloom’s performance still lingers as a weaker element in an otherwise strong movie.

9

Tom Hanks as Colonel Tom Parker

‘Elvis’ (2022)

Tom Hanks underwent a dramatic transformation to portray Colonel Tom Parker in Baz Luhrmann’s Elvis, spending hours in makeup to achieve the character’s distinctive appearance. Despite his commitment, his performance is quite over the top, resembling a comic book villain that didn’t quite align with Austin Butler‘s more grounded and captivating depiction of Elvis Presley. To make matters worse, Hanks’s accent also drew criticism for being confusing and inconsistent.

Hanks’s performance even earned him his first-ever Razzie Award for Worst Supporting Actor and Worst Screen Combo (shared with his latex face). But while Hanks’s portrayal may have been odd, the true standout of the film was undeniably Austin Butler. Elvis was a commercial and critical hit, racking up multiple Oscar nominations, including Best Picture and Best Actor for Butler. Though Butler ultimately lost the Best Actor award to Brendan Fraser, his portrayal of Elvis was widely praised, and he actually sang Presley’s early songs in the film.

8

Rinko Kikuchi as Mako Mori

‘Pacific Rim’ (2013)

In Pacific Rim, Rinko Kikuchi plays Mako Mori, a young woman who has dreamed of piloting a Jaeger — massive robots designed to fight colossal creatures known as Kaiju — for as long as she can remember. Initially rejected due to her lack of experience, she ultimately proves herself to be a skilled and capable pilot. The character is portrayed at both a young age and as an adult, with Kikuchi playing the adult Mako. While the portrayal of young Mako was widely praised, some viewers felt that the adult version didn’t fully capture the same depth and emotion.

Many argued that Kikuchi’s performance lacked the spark that made the younger Mako so engaging, leading to a portrayal that felt somewhat flat and hollow. Despite these critiques, Pacific Rim built a dedicated fan base. The story and the characters may be simple, but the movie is nothing short of a spectacle. Finding the perfect balance between fighting the monsters and the human characters, Pacific Rim is one of the best monster movies of the 21st century.

7

Wiley Wiggins as Mitch Kramer

‘Dazed and Confused’ (1993)

Dazed and Confused helped launch the careers of several actors, including Matthew McConaughey, whose catchphrase “Alright, alright, alright” became iconic. At just 16 years old, Wiley Wiggins played Mitch Kramer, a freshman trying to navigate the ups and downs of high school life in the 1970s. Wiggins hadn’t planned on acting; he was discovered by a casting director while leaving a coffee shop in Austin.

Despite the film’s overall charm, some viewers found Wiggins’s performance a bit awkward, and his inexperience showed. Dazed and Confused didn’t make a big splash at the box office but found a second life on home video and has since become a beloved cult classic. Critics have praised it for its authentic portrayal of high school life, capturing the essence of teenage experiences in a way that’s both relatable and nostalgic.

6

Kate Capshaw as Willie Scott

‘Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom’ (1984)

Kate Capshaw had a few screen credits to her name by 1983, but it was her role as Willie Scott in Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom that made her a star. Over 1,000 actresses auditioned for the role of Willie Scott, including the then-unknown Sharon Stone. Ultimately, Spielberg chose Capshaw after viewing her audition tape and sharing it with Harrison Ford.

The character of Willie Scott was often criticized for her constant screaming, exaggerated reactions, and reliance on Indiana Jones for rescue. While the script didn’t offer much depth for her character, some felt that Capshaw’s performance amplified these shortcomings. After Temple of Doom, Capshaw didn’t land another role of that magnitude, although she demonstrated her acting abilities in smaller projects.

5

Mickey Rooney as Mr. Yunioshi

‘Breakfast at Tiffany’s (1961)

Based on a story by the legendary Truman Capote, Breakfast at Tiffany’s is a rom-com where a young New York socialite named Holly becomes interested in a young man who’s moved into her apartment building, but her past threatens to get in the way. Holly’s problematic upstairs neighbor is the Japanese photographer Mr. Yunioshi, who loves nothing more than to interrupt Holly’s life with noise complaints.

Even back in 1961, Mickey Rooney’s repulsively offensive of a caricaturistic Asian stereotype was widely criticized as tone-deaf. Over sixty years later, it’s an even more heavily criticized performance. Rooney was always hilarious, but his work here is some of the most displeasing of his whole career. Breakfast at Tiffany’s is an incredible movie overall, perhaps one of the best Classic Hollywood films for beginners, but this particular secondary character is the part that’s aged the worst about it. —Diego Pineda Pacheco

4

Russell Crowe as Javert

‘Les Misérables’ (2012)

Russell Crowe took on the formidable role of Inspector Javert in Tom Hooper‘s adaptation of Les Misérables, a character that required not just strong acting but also significant singing talent. While Crowe is an acclaimed actor with a successful career, his musical endeavors have received mixed reviews, and his portrayal of Javert was no exception. Indeed, his vocal performance didn’t quite match the character, and the decision to record nearly every song live on set further drew attention to his awkward and strained technique.

Although Crowe’s performance felt out of place, the movie was a success, winning several accolades. Les Misérables went on to win three Academy Awards and was noted for its sweeping scale and heartfelt storytelling, effectively bringing Victor Hugo’s classic to life on the big screen. Yet, for those seeking a more compelling adaptation of this iconic tale, there are arguably stronger versions worth watching.

3

Keanu Reeves as Jonathan Harker

‘Bram Stoker’s Dracula’ (1992)

Keanu Reeves captivated audiences with his roles as Neo in The Matrix series and John Wick in the John Wick franchise, but his venture outside of action films in Bram Stoker’s Dracula wasn’t as well-received. In Francis Ford Coppola‘s gothic movie, he portrayed Jonathan Harker, a young lawyer drawn into the dark world of Count Dracula. Unfortunately, his attempt at an English accent was widely criticized as unconvincing, and his portrayal lacked the emotional depth needed for the character. Acting alongside titans like Gary Oldman and Anthony Hopkins only made Reeves’s performance stand out more, and not in a good way.

Despite these critiques, Reeves’s dedication to the role was clear, and his experience in Dracula likely shaped his future career choices. After the film, he leaned back into roles that played to his strengths — action-packed and science fiction-heavy films that are a better fit for his talents. While Reeves’s performance as Jonathan Harker might not have been his most celebrated, Bram Stoker’s Dracula is considered one of Coppola’s best films, with Reeves’s participation a notable, if imperfect, part of its legacy.

2

Quentin Tarantino as Frankie

‘Django Unchained’ (2012)

Quentin Tarantino is widely celebrated as one of the greatest directors of all time, known for his distinctive style and bold storytelling. However, his ventures into acting have not garnered the same level of praise. In Django Unchained, Tarantino cast himself in the role of Frankie, a minor character who appears later in the film. His performance drew criticism for being awkward and distracting, particularly due to an Australian accent that many found unconvincing. His cameo broke the immersion of the film, feeling more like a self-indulgent insert than a meaningful contribution to the story.

This wasn’t the first time Tarantino stepped in front of the camera in his work. He also played Jimmie in Pulp Fiction, a role that has been debated among fans and critics. While his passion for filmmaking is undeniable, Tarantino’s performances often highlight his strengths as a director rather than an actor. These cameos, although fun for some, are often seen as missteps that momentarily pull the audience out of the narrative.

1

Sofia Coppola as Mary Corleone

‘The Godfather Part III’ (1990)

Paramount had been asking Francis Ford Coppola to make a third installment of The Godfather for many years, but he kept turning them down. It wasn’t until he was in a severe financial crisis due to the failure of One from the Heart that he finally had to agree to make The Godfather Part III. Fans aren’t exactly happy about that. It’s a great film overall, but nowhere even near the level of transcendental quality of its two predecessors. It follows Michael Corleone, now in his 60s, seeking to free his family from crime and find a suitable successor to his empire.

A rather massive reason why Godfather III is so heavily disliked by many—perhaps even the main reason—is the bizarre subplot about Michael’s daughter, Mary, falling in love with her much older cousin, Vincent. What makes matters even worse is that poor Sofia Coppola, who only took the role of Mary at her father’s exhortation after Winona Ryder dropped out, clearly didn’t have even a fraction of the acting chops necessary to make the role work at least a little. Her performance here is a bumbling, confused, entirely unappealing piece of work, and if it wasn’t in the movie, it wouldn’t be hard to imagine it being more often praised as the great film that it genuinely is. —Diego Pineda Pacheco

NEXT: The Worst Hollywood Remakes of International Horror Movies, Ranked